{"id":17738,"date":"2017-12-17T16:35:00","date_gmt":"2017-12-17T09:35:00","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/luatsubaoho.com\/phapluat\/?p=17738"},"modified":"2021-04-13T15:28:29","modified_gmt":"2021-04-13T08:28:29","slug":"an-le-so-12-2017-al-ve-xac-dinh-truong-hop-duong-su-duoc-trieu-tap-hop-le-lan-thu-nhat-sau-khi-toa-an-da-hoan-phien-toa","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/luatsubaoho.com\/phapluat\/an-le-so-12-2017-al-ve-xac-dinh-truong-hop-duong-su-duoc-trieu-tap-hop-le-lan-thu-nhat-sau-khi-toa-an-da-hoan-phien-toa\/","title":{"rendered":"\u00c1n l\u1ec7 s\u1ed1 12\/2017\/AL v\u1ec1 x\u00e1c \u0111\u1ecbnh tr\u01b0\u1eddng h\u1ee3p \u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng s\u1ef1 \u0111\u01b0\u1ee3c tri\u1ec7u t\u1eadp h\u1ee3p l\u1ec7 l\u1ea7n th\u1ee9 nh\u1ea5t sau khi T\u00f2a \u00e1n \u0111\u00e3 ho\u00e3n phi\u00ean t\u00f2a"},"content":{"rendered":"\n

\u00c1n l\u1ec7 s\u1ed1 12\/2017\/AL v\u1ec1 x\u00e1c \u0111\u1ecbnh tr\u01b0\u1eddng h\u1ee3p \u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng s\u1ef1 \u0111\u01b0\u1ee3c tri\u1ec7u t\u1eadp h\u1ee3p l\u1ec7 l\u1ea7n th\u1ee9 nh\u1ea5t sau khi T\u00f2a \u00e1n \u0111\u00e3 ho\u00e3n phi\u00ean t\u00f2a, \u0111\u01b0\u1ee3c H\u1ed9i \u0111\u1ed3ng Th\u1ea9m ph\u00e1n T\u00f2a \u00e1n nh\u00e2n d\u00e2n t\u1ed1i cao th\u00f4ng qua ng\u00e0y 14 th\u00e1ng 12 n\u0103m 2017 v\u00e0 \u0111\u01b0\u1ee3c c\u00f4ng b\u1ed1 theo Quy\u1ebft \u0111\u1ecbnh s\u1ed1 299\/Q\u0110-CA ng\u00e0y 28 th\u00e1ng 12 n\u0103m 2017 c\u1ee7a Ch\u00e1nh \u00e1n T\u00f2a \u00e1n nh\u00e2n d\u00e2n t\u1ed1i cao.<\/p>\n

\n
\n

Ngu\u1ed3n \u00e1n l\u1ec7:<\/strong><\/p>\n

Quy\u1ebft \u0111\u1ecbnh gi\u00e1m \u0111\u1ed1c th\u1ea9m s\u1ed1 14\/2017\/KDTM-G\u0110T ng\u00e0y 06-6-2017 c\u1ee7a H\u1ed9i \u0111\u1ed3ng Th\u1ea9m ph\u00e1n T\u00f2a \u00e1n nh\u00e2n d\u00e2n t\u1ed1i cao v\u1ec1 v\u1ee5 \u00e1n kinh doanh, th\u01b0\u01a1ng m\u1ea1i \u201cTranh ch\u1ea5p v\u1ec1 h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng mua b\u00e1n h\u00e0ng ho\u00e1\u201d t\u1ea1i t\u1ec9nh Qu\u1ea3ng Tr\u1ecb gi\u1eefa\u00a0nguy\u00ean \u0111\u01a1n l\u00e0 C\u00f4ng ty c\u1ed5 ph\u1ea7n Q (ng\u01b0\u1eddi \u0111\u1ea1i di\u1ec7n theo ph\u00e1p lu\u1eadt l\u00e0 \u00f4ng \u0110\u1eb7ng C\u00f4ng D, ng\u01b0\u1eddi \u0111\u1ea1i di\u1ec7n theo \u1ee7y quy\u1ec1n l\u00e0\u00a0\u00f4ng\u00a0H\u1ed3 Ngh\u0129a A) v\u1edbi b\u1ecb \u0111\u01a1n l\u00e0 C\u00f4ng ty tr\u00e1ch nhi\u1ec7m h\u1eefu h\u1ea1n T (ng\u01b0\u1eddi \u0111\u1ea1i di\u1ec7n theo ph\u00e1p lu\u1eadt l\u00e0\u00a0\u00f4ng\u00a0V\u00f5 V\u0103n T, ng\u01b0\u1eddi \u0111\u1ea1i di\u1ec7n theo \u1ee7y quy\u1ec1n l\u00e0\u00a0b\u00e0\u00a0V\u00f5 Th\u1ecb T)\u00a0.<\/p>\n

V\u1ecb tr\u00ed n\u1ed9i dung \u00e1n l\u1ec7:<\/strong><\/p>\n

\u0110o\u1ea1n 1 ph\u1ea7n \u201cNh\u1eadn \u0111\u1ecbnh c\u1ee7a To\u00e0 \u00e1n\u201d.<\/p>\n

Kh\u00e1i qu\u00e1t n\u1ed9i dung c\u1ee7a \u00e1n l\u1ec7:<\/strong><\/p>\n

\u2013 T\u00ecnh hu\u1ed1ng \u00e1n l\u1ec7:<\/strong><\/em><\/p>\n

T\u00f2a \u00e1n\u00a0\u0111\u00e3\u00a0quy\u1ebft \u0111\u1ecbnh\u00a0ho\u00e3n\u00a0phi\u00ean t\u00f2a\u00a0v\u00e0\u00a0l\u00fd do\u00a0ho\u00e3n phi\u00ean t\u00f2a\u00a0kh\u00f4ng ph\u1ea3i do l\u1ed7i c\u1ee7a\u00a0\u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng s\u1ef1 (nguy\u00ean \u0111\u01a1n, b\u1ecb \u0111\u01a1n, ng\u01b0\u1eddi c\u00f3 quy\u1ec1n l\u1ee3i,\u00a0ngh\u0129a v\u1ee5 li\u00ean quan)\u00a0ho\u1eb7c ng\u01b0\u1eddi \u0111\u1ea1i di\u1ec7n, ng\u01b0\u1eddi b\u1ea3o v\u1ec7 quy\u1ec1n v\u00e0 l\u1ee3i \u00edch h\u1ee3p ph\u00e1p c\u1ee7a \u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng s\u1ef1. Phi\u00ean t\u00f2a\u00a0\u0111\u01b0\u1ee3c m\u1edf l\u1ea1i nh\u01b0ng c\u00f3 \u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng s\u1ef1 ho\u1eb7c ng\u01b0\u1eddi \u0111\u1ea1i di\u1ec7n, ng\u01b0\u1eddi b\u1ea3o v\u1ec7 quy\u1ec1n v\u00e0 l\u1ee3i \u00edch h\u1ee3p ph\u00e1p c\u1ee7a \u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng s\u1ef1 \u0111\u01b0\u1ee3c tri\u1ec7u t\u1eadp h\u1ee3p l\u1ec7 v\u1eafng m\u1eb7t.<\/p>\n

\u2013 Gi\u1ea3i ph\u00e1p ph\u00e1p l\u00fd:<\/strong><\/em><\/p>\n

T\u00f2a \u00e1n ph\u1ea3i x\u00e1c \u0111\u1ecbnh \u0111\u00e2y l\u00e0 tr\u01b0\u1eddng h\u1ee3p \u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng s\u1ef1 ho\u1eb7c ng\u01b0\u1eddi \u0111\u1ea1i di\u1ec7n, ng\u01b0\u1eddi b\u1ea3o v\u1ec7 quy\u1ec1n v\u00e0 l\u1ee3i \u00edch h\u1ee3p ph\u00e1p c\u1ee7a \u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng s\u1ef1 \u0111\u01b0\u1ee3c tri\u1ec7u t\u1eadp h\u1ee3p l\u1ec7 l\u1ea7n th\u1ee9 nh\u1ea5t v\u1eafng m\u1eb7t t\u1ea1i phi\u00ean t\u00f2a.<\/p>\n

Quy \u0111\u1ecbnh c\u1ee7a ph\u00e1p lu\u1eadt li\u00ean quan \u0111\u1ebfn \u00e1n l\u1ec7:<\/p>\n

Kho\u1ea3n 1 \u0110i\u1ec1u 199, \u0110i\u1ec1u 202, kho\u1ea3n 2 \u0110i\u1ec1u 266 B\u1ed9 lu\u1eadt T\u1ed1 t\u1ee5ng d\u00e2n s\u1ef1 n\u0103m 2004 (kho\u1ea3n 1 \u0110i\u1ec1u 227, \u0110i\u1ec1u 228, kho\u1ea3n 2 \u0110i\u1ec1u 296 B\u1ed9 lu\u1eadt T\u1ed1 t\u1ee5ng d\u00e2n s\u1ef1 n\u0103m 2015).<\/p>\n

T\u1eeb kh\u00f3a c\u1ee7a \u00e1n l\u1ec7:<\/em><\/strong><\/p>\n

\u201cTri\u1ec7u t\u1eadp h\u1ee3p l\u1ec7\u201d;\u00a0\u201cTri\u1ec7u t\u1eadp h\u1ee3p l\u1ec7 l\u1ea7n th\u1ee9 nh\u1ea5t\u201d; \u201c\u0110\u01b0\u01a1ng s\u1ef1 v\u1eafng m\u1eb7t t\u1ea1i phi\u00ean t\u00f2a\u201d; \u201cHo\u00e3n phi\u00ean t\u00f2a\u201d.<\/p>\n

N\u1ed8I DUNG V\u1ee4 \u00c1N:<\/strong><\/p>\n

T\u1ea1i \u0110\u01a1n kh\u1edfi ki\u1ec7n \u0111\u1ec1 ng\u00e0y 05-11-2012; \u0110\u01a1n s\u1eeda \u0111\u1ed5i, b\u1ed5 sung \u0111\u01a1n kh\u1edfi ki\u1ec7n \u0111\u1ec1 ng\u00e0y 26-5-2013 v\u00e0 c\u00e1c l\u1eddi khai t\u1ea1i T\u00f2a \u00e1n, nguy\u00ean \u0111\u01a1n l\u00e0 C\u00f4ng ty c\u1ed5 ph\u1ea7n Q tr\u00ecnh b\u00e0y:<\/p>\n

Ng\u00e0y 03-01-2011, C\u00f4ng ty c\u1ed5 ph\u1ea7n Q (sau \u0111\u00e2y vi\u1ebft t\u1eaft l\u00e0 C\u00f4ng ty Q) v\u00e0 C\u00f4ng ty tr\u00e1ch nhi\u1ec7m h\u1eefu h\u1ea1n T (sau \u0111\u00e2y vi\u1ebft t\u1eaft l\u00e0 C\u00f4ng ty T) k\u00fd k\u1ebft H\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng mua b\u00e1n c\u00e2y gi\u1ed1ng cao su s\u1ed1 011\/2011\/H\u0110KT; ng\u00e0y 23-02-2011, hai b\u00ean ti\u1ebfp t\u1ee5c k\u00fd H\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng s\u1ed1 021\/2011\/H\u0110KT v\u1edbi c\u00f9ng n\u1ed9i dung. T\u1ed5ng s\u1ed1 l\u01b0\u1ee3ng c\u00e2y c\u1ee7a hai h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng l\u00e0 400.000 c\u00e2y cao su gi\u1ed1ng b\u1ea7u 02 t\u1ea7ng l\u00e1 c\u00f3 gi\u00e1 tr\u1ecb 2.800.000.000 K\u00edp L\u00e0o (m\u1ed7i h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng 200.000 c\u00e2y, tr\u1ecb gi\u00e1 1.400.000.000 K\u00edp L\u00e0o). Sau khi k\u00fd h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng, C\u00f4ng ty Q \u0111\u00e3 t\u1ea1m \u1ee9ng cho C\u00f4ng ty T 930.000.000 K\u00edp L\u00e0o (t\u01b0\u01a1ng \u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng v\u1edbi 2.511.000.000 \u0111\u1ed3ng).<\/p>\n

Qu\u00e1 tr\u00ecnh th\u1ef1c hi\u1ec7n h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng, C\u00f4ng ty T \u0111\u1ec1 ngh\u1ecb m\u01b0\u1ee3n 449.455 c\u00e2y Stump tr\u1ea7n v\u00e0 \u0111\u01b0\u1ee3c C\u00f4ng ty Q ch\u1ea5p nh\u1eadn, s\u1ed1 c\u00e2y n\u00e0y C\u00f4ng ty Q k\u00fd h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng mua c\u1ee7a C\u00f4ng ty V v\u1edbi gi\u00e1 6.500 \u0111\u1ed3ng\/c\u00e2y. C\u00f4ng ty T \u0111\u00e3 tr\u1ea3 cho C\u00f4ng ty Q 40.600 c\u00e2y, hi\u1ec7n c\u00f2n n\u1ee3 408.855 c\u00e2y. \u0110\u1ee3t 1, C\u00f4ng ty T ch\u1ec9 giao \u0111\u01b0\u1ee3c 79.924 c\u00e2y sau \u0111\u00f3 kh\u00f4ng th\u1ef1c hi\u1ec7n h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng. C\u00f4ng ty Q \u0111\u00e3 nhi\u1ec1u l\u1ea7n m\u1eddi C\u00f4ng ty T \u0111\u1ebfn \u0111\u1ec3 gi\u1ea3i quy\u1ebft, nh\u01b0ng C\u00f4ng ty T kh\u00f4ng \u0111\u1ebfn. Ng\u00e0y 05-10-2011,\u00f4ng V\u00f5 V\u0103n T m\u1edbi c\u1eed con g\u00e1i l\u00e0 b\u00e0 V\u00f5 Th\u1ecb T \u0111\u1ebfn l\u00e0m vi\u1ec7c. \u0110\u1ec3 h\u1ea1n ch\u1ebf thi\u1ec7t h\u1ea1i x\u1ea3y ra, C\u00f4ng ty Q \u0111\u00e3 ti\u1ebfn h\u00e0nh ki\u1ec3m k\u00ea to\u00e0n b\u1ed9 s\u1ed1 l\u01b0\u1ee3ng c\u00e2y hi\u1ec7n c\u00f3. T\u00ednh \u0111\u1ebfn ng\u00e0y 14-9-2011, t\u1ed5ng c\u1ed9ng c\u00f3 194.776 c\u00e2y, nh\u01b0ng \u0111\u00e2y ch\u1ec9 l\u00e0 s\u1ed1 l\u01b0\u1ee3ng ki\u1ec3m k\u00ea ch\u1ee9 kh\u00f4ng ph\u1ea3i s\u1ed1 l\u01b0\u1ee3ng giao nh\u1eadn. N\u1ebfu k\u1ebft th\u00fac \u1edf th\u1eddi \u0111i\u1ec3m giao nh\u1eadn th\u00e1ng 9-2011 th\u00ec s\u1ed1 l\u01b0\u1ee3ng c\u00e2y giao nh\u1eadn ch\u1ec9 \u0111\u1ea1t 20% tr\u00ean t\u1ed5ng s\u1ed1 ti\u1ec1n l\u00e0 76% m\u00e0 C\u00f4ng ty T \u0111\u00e3 nh\u1eadn \u1ee9ng tr\u01b0\u1edbc c\u1ee7a C\u00f4ng ty Q. Do \u0111\u00f3, C\u00f4ng ty Q \u0111\u00e3 th\u1ed1ng nh\u1ea5t v\u1edbi b\u00e0 V\u00f5 Th\u1ecb T \u0111\u1ec3 C\u00f4ng ty Q c\u1eed c\u00f4ng nh\u00e2n \u0111\u1ebfn t\u1eadn d\u1ee5ng v\u00e0 b\u1ee9ng ti\u1ebfp \u0111\u1ee3t 2 l\u00e0 117.833 c\u00e2y, n\u00e2ng t\u1ed5ng s\u1ed1 c\u00e2y giao nh\u1eadn l\u00ean 197.757 c\u00e2y Stump, t\u01b0\u01a1ng \u1ee9ng t\u1ed5ng tr\u1ecb gi\u00e1 3.623.897.000 \u0111\u1ed3ng.<\/p>\n

Ngo\u00e0i ra, C\u00f4ng ty Q c\u00f2n cho C\u00f4ng ty T m\u01b0\u1ee3n c\u00e1c lo\u1ea1i v\u1eadt t\u01b0, ph\u00e2n b\u00f3n v\u1edbi t\u1ed5ng gi\u00e1 tr\u1ecb l\u00e0 243.913.21l \u0111\u1ed3ng, nh\u01b0ng \u0111\u1ebfn nay C\u00f4ng ty T v\u1eabn ch\u01b0a tr\u1ea3 l\u1ea1i.<\/p>\n

C\u00f4ng ty T \u0111\u00e3 giao cho C\u00f4ng ty Q 163.376 b\u1ea7u \u0111\u1ea5t gia c\u00f4ng, tr\u1ecb gi\u00e1 39.414.000 K\u00edp L\u00e0o, t\u01b0\u01a1ng \u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng 105.629.500 \u0111\u1ed3ng; v\u01b0\u1eddn g\u1ed7 nh\u00e2n tr\u1ecb gi\u00e1 20.491.200 K\u00edp L\u00e0o, t\u01b0\u01a1ng \u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng 54.916.000 \u0111\u1ed3ng v\u00e0 18.096.000 \u0111\u1ed3ng; t\u1ed5ng c\u1ed9ng l\u00e0 178.641.500 \u0111\u1ed3ng. Nay C\u00f4ng ty Q y\u00eau c\u1ea7u T\u00f2a \u00e1n gi\u1ea3i quy\u1ebft:<\/p>\n

\u2013\u00a0Bu\u1ed9c C\u00f4ng ty T\u00a0b\u1ed3i th\u01b0\u1eddng thi\u1ec7t h\u1ea1i do vi ph\u1ea1m ngh\u0129a v\u1ee5 th\u1ef1c hi\u1ec7n hai h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng n\u00eau tr\u00ean v\u1edbi t\u1ed5ng s\u1ed1 c\u00e2y gi\u1ed1ng ch\u01b0a giao \u0111\u1ee7 l\u00e0 202.243 c\u00e2y (tr\u1ecb gi\u00e1 th\u00e0nh ti\u1ec1n l\u00e0 3.706.102.975 \u0111\u1ed3ng). Theo h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng hai b\u00ean \u0111\u00e3 c\u00f3 th\u1ecfa thu\u1eadn n\u1ebfu vi ph\u1ea1m c\u00f2n ph\u1ea3i ch\u1ecbu ph\u1ea1t g\u1ea5p 05 l\u1ea7n gi\u00e1 tr\u1ecb s\u1ed1 c\u00e2y ch\u01b0a giao \u0111\u1ee7 l\u00e0 18.530.514.875 \u0111\u1ed3ng;<\/p>\n

\u2013\u00a0Bu\u1ed9c C\u00f4ng ty T ph\u1ea3i tr\u1ea3\u00a0408.855 c\u00e2y\u00a0gi\u1ed1ng Stump tr\u1ea7n \u0111\u00e3 m\u01b0\u1ee3n c\u1ee7a C\u00f4ng ty Q, tr\u1ecb gi\u00e1 th\u00e0nh ti\u1ec1n l\u00e0 2.657.557.500 \u0111\u1ed3ng;<\/p>\n

\u2013\u00a0Bu\u1ed9c C\u00f4ng ty T ph\u1ea3i tr\u1ea3 c\u00e1c lo\u1ea1i v\u1eadt t\u01b0 \u0111\u00e3 m\u01b0\u1ee3n c\u1ee7a C\u00f4ng ty Q bao g\u1ed3m: T\u00fai b\u1ea7u PE (18 x 40) 5.170kg, ph\u00e2n Kali 500kg, ph\u00e2n DAP 1.000kg, ph\u00e2n l\u00e2n 2.800kg v\u1edbi t\u1ed5ng tr\u1ecb gi\u00e1 91.212.392 K\u00edp L\u00e0o, t\u01b0\u01a1ng \u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng 243.913.21l \u0111\u1ed3ng.<\/p>\n

T\u1ea1i phi\u00ean t\u00f2a, C\u00f4ng ty Q ch\u1ec9 y\u00eau c\u1ea7u ph\u1ea1t vi ph\u1ea1m h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng 8% \u0111\u1ed1i v\u1edbi gi\u00e1 tr\u1ecb s\u1ed1 c\u00e2y ch\u01b0a giao \u0111\u1ee7 l\u00e0 296.488.000 \u0111\u1ed3ng. T\u1ed5ng c\u1ed9ng C\u00f4ng ty T ph\u1ea3i tr\u1ea3 cho C\u00f4ng ty Q 3.088.822.500 \u0111\u1ed3ng. Sau khi \u0111\u1ed1i tr\u1eeb s\u1ed1 ti\u1ec1n C\u00f4ng ty Q ph\u1ea3i thanh to\u00e1n cho C\u00f4ng ty T l\u00e0 1.367.934.000 \u0111\u1ed3ng th\u00ec C\u00f4ng ty T c\u00f2n ph\u1ea3i tr\u1ea3 cho C\u00f4ng ty Q s\u1ed1 ti\u1ec1n l\u00e0 1.720.888.500 \u0111\u1ed3ng.<\/p>\n

B\u1ecb \u0111\u01a1n l\u00e0 C\u00f4ng ty tr\u00e1ch nhi\u1ec7m h\u1eefu h\u1ea1n T tr\u00ecnh b\u00e0y:<\/p>\n

X\u00e1c nh\u1eadn n\u1ed9i dung h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng nh\u01b0 C\u00f4ng ty Q \u0111\u00e3 tr\u00ecnh b\u00e0y. C\u00f4ng ty T \u0111\u00e3 th\u1ef1c hi\u1ec7n \u0111\u00fang h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng, nh\u01b0ng khi \u0111\u1ebfn th\u1eddi h\u1ea1n giao c\u00e2y th\u00ec C\u00f4ng ty Q tr\u00ec ho\u00e3n kh\u00f4ng nh\u1eadn c\u00e2y v\u1edbi l\u00fd do ch\u01b0a \u0111\u1ee7 c\u00f4ng nh\u00e2n, ch\u01b0a c\u00f3 ph\u01b0\u01a1ng ti\u1ec7n v\u1eadn chuy\u1ec3n c\u00e2y \u0111i. \u0110\u1ea1i di\u1ec7n c\u1ee7a C\u00f4ng ty Q cho bi\u1ebft do k\u1ebf ho\u1ea1ch tr\u1ed3ng c\u00e2y cao su c\u1ee7a C\u00f4ng ty t\u1ea1i th\u1eddi \u0111i\u1ec3m \u0111\u00f3 so v\u1edbi n\u0103m tr\u01b0\u1edbc \u0111\u00e3 b\u1ecb c\u1eaft gi\u1ea3m di\u1ec7n t\u00edch tr\u1ed3ng n\u00ean kh\u00f4ng bi\u1ebft nh\u1eadn c\u00e2y xong s\u1ebd tr\u1ed3ng \u1edf \u0111\u00e2u. Do \u0111\u00f3, \u0111\u1ebfn ng\u00e0y 19-7-2011, C\u00f4ng ty Q m\u1edbi ch\u1ecbu nh\u1eadn \u0111\u1ee3t 1 l\u00e0 79.924 c\u00e2y v\u00e0 \u0111\u1ebfn ng\u00e0y 21-9-2011 m\u1edbi v\u1eadn chuy\u1ec3n h\u1ebft s\u1ed1 c\u00e2y n\u00f3i tr\u00ean. C\u00f4ng ty T \u0111\u00e3 nhi\u1ec1u l\u1ea7n y\u00eau c\u1ea7u C\u00f4ng ty Q nh\u1eadn s\u1ed1 c\u00e2y c\u00f2n l\u1ea1i nh\u01b0ng C\u00f4ng ty Q kh\u00f4ng \u0111\u1ebfn nh\u1eadn. \u0110\u1ebfn \u0111\u1ea7u th\u00e1ng 9-2011, C\u00f4ng ty Q h\u1eb9n C\u00f4ng ty T v\u00e0o ng\u00e0y 14-9-2011 s\u1ebd c\u1eed nh\u00e2n vi\u00ean k\u1ef9 thu\u1eadt \u0111\u1ebfn ki\u1ec3m tra s\u1ed1 c\u00e2y c\u00f2n l\u1ea1i, n\u1ebfu s\u1eed d\u1ee5ng \u0111\u01b0\u1ee3c th\u00ec \u0111\u1ebfm nh\u1eadn v\u00e0 xin \u0111\u1ec3 nh\u1edd t\u1ea1i v\u01b0\u1eddn \u01b0\u01a1m c\u1ee7a C\u00f4ng ty T, \u0111\u1ebfn khi n\u00e0o c\u00f3 k\u1ebf ho\u1ea1ch s\u1ebd tr\u1ed3ng. S\u1ed1 c\u00e2y m\u00e0 C\u00f4ng ty Q \u0111\u1ebfm v\u00e0o ng\u00e0y 14-9-2011 l\u00e0 194.766 c\u00e2y, c\u1ed9ng v\u1edbi s\u1ed1 c\u00e2y nh\u1eadn \u0111\u1ee3t 1 l\u00e0 79.924 c\u00e2y, t\u1ed5ng c\u1ed9ng C\u00f4ng ty Q \u0111\u00e3 nh\u1eadn 274.690 c\u00e2y. S\u1ed1 c\u00e2y qu\u00e1 th\u1eddi h\u1ea1n m\u00e0 C\u00f4ng ty Q kh\u00f4ng nh\u1eadn d\u1eabn \u0111\u1ebfn b\u1ecb ch\u1ebft l\u00e0 125.310 c\u00e2y. Nh\u01b0 v\u1eady, \u0111\u1ed1i v\u1edbi s\u1ed1 l\u01b0\u1ee3ng 400.000 c\u00e2y c\u1ee7a hai h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng th\u00ec C\u00f4ng ty T \u0111\u00e3 cung c\u1ea5p \u0111\u1ee7. L\u1ed7i kh\u00f4ng nh\u1eadn c\u00e2y d\u1eabn \u0111\u1ebfn s\u1ed1 c\u00e2y b\u1ecb ch\u1ebft l\u00e0 do C\u00f4ng ty Q. Ngh\u0129a v\u1ee5 th\u1ef1c hi\u1ec7n vi\u1ec7c giao c\u00e2y t\u1eeb hai h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng \u0111\u00e3 \u0111\u01b0\u1ee3c C\u00f4ng ty T th\u1ef1c hi\u1ec7n xong. S\u1ed1 ti\u1ec1n c\u00f2n l\u1ea1i t\u1eeb hai h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng C\u00f4ng ty T \u0111\u00e3 nhi\u1ec1u l\u1ea7n y\u00eau c\u1ea7u thanh to\u00e1n nh\u01b0ng C\u00f4ng ty Q kh\u00f4ng ch\u1ecbu tr\u1ea3.<\/p>\n

C\u00f4ng ty Q \u0111\u00e3 \u1ee9ng ti\u1ec1n cho C\u00f4ng ty T theo hai\u00a0h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng l\u00e0 930.000.000 K\u00edp L\u00e0o, t\u01b0\u01a1ng \u1ee9ng v\u1edbi 2.511.000.000 \u0111\u1ed3ng. S\u1ed1 ph\u00e2n b\u00f3n, v\u1eadt t\u01b0 m\u00e0 C\u00f4ng ty Q cho C\u00f4ng ty T m\u01b0\u1ee3n l\u00e0 91.212.392 K\u00edp L\u00e0o. T\u1ed5ng c\u1ed9ng s\u1ed1 ti\u1ec1n C\u00f4ng ty T ph\u1ea3i tr\u1ea3 cho C\u00f4ng ty Q l\u00e0 1.021.212.392 K\u00edp L\u00e0o, t\u01b0\u01a1ng \u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng 2.757.273.454 \u0111\u1ed3ng.<\/p>\n

T\u1ed5ng gi\u00e1 tr\u1ecb c\u1ee7a hai h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng m\u00e0 C\u00f4ng ty T \u0111\u00e3 th\u1ef1c hi\u1ec7n xong l\u00e0 2.800.000.000 K\u00edp L\u00e0o. C\u00f4ng ty Q \u0111\u00e3 nh\u1eadn v\u01b0\u1eddn g\u1ed7 nh\u00e2n c\u1ee7a C\u00f4ng ty T tr\u1ecb gi\u00e1 20.491.200 K\u00edp\u00a0L\u00e0o v\u00e0 18.096.000 \u0111\u1ed3ng. T\u00fai b\u1ea7u PE m\u00e0 C\u00f4ng ty Q \u0111\u00e3 nh\u1eadn c\u1ee7a C\u00f4ng ty T \u0111\u1ee3t 1 l\u00e0 32.865.000 K\u00edp L\u00e0o, \u0111\u1ee3t 2 l\u00e0 7.875.000 K\u00edp L\u00e0o, ti\u1ec1n gia c\u00f4ng v\u00e0o \u0111\u1ea5t b\u1ea7u l\u00e0 39.406.291 K\u00edp L\u00e0o. Nh\u01b0 v\u1eady, t\u1ed5ng s\u1ed1 ti\u1ec1n m\u00e0 C\u00f4ng ty Q ph\u1ea3i c\u00f3 ngh\u0129a v\u1ee5 tr\u1ea3 cho C\u00f4ng ty T l\u00e0 2.900.637.491 K\u00edp L\u00e0o t\u01b0\u01a1ng \u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng 7.831.721.225 \u0111\u1ed3ng. Sau khi \u0111\u1ed1i tr\u1eeb ngh\u0129a v\u1ee5 c\u1ee7a c\u00e1c b\u00ean, C\u00f4ng ty T ph\u1ea3n t\u1ed1 y\u00eau c\u1ea7u C\u00f4ng ty Q ph\u1ea3i thanh to\u00e1n s\u1ed1 ti\u1ec1n 1.879.425.009 K\u00edp L\u00e0o (t\u01b0\u01a1ng \u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng 5.074.447.767 \u0111\u1ed3ng) v\u00e0 18.096.000 \u0111\u1ed3ng. T\u1ed5ng c\u1ed9ng l\u00e0 5.092.543.767 \u0111\u1ed3ng.<\/p>\n

T\u1ea1i phi\u00ean t\u00f2a, C\u00f4ng ty T ch\u1ec9 y\u00eau c\u1ea7u thanh to\u00e1n c\u00e1c kho\u1ea3n sau:<\/p>\n

\u2013 Gi\u00e1 tr\u1ecb 400.000 c\u00e2y gi\u1ed1ng \u0111\u00e3 th\u1ef1c hi\u1ec7n theo h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng l\u00e0 1.870.000.000 K\u00edp L\u00e0o (sau khi \u0111\u00e3 tr\u1eeb s\u1ed1 ti\u1ec1n C\u00f4ng ty Q \u1ee9ng l\u00e0 930.000.000 K\u00edp L\u00e0o), t\u01b0\u01a1ng \u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng 4.895.288.000 \u0111\u1ed3ng;<\/p>\n

\u2013 Gi\u00e1 tr\u1ecb v\u01b0\u1eddn g\u1ed7 nh\u00e2n l\u00e0 20.491.200 K\u00edp L\u00e0o, t\u01b0\u01a1ng \u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng 53.642.000 \u0111\u1ed3ng v\u00e0 18.096.000 \u0111\u1ed3ng;<\/p>\n

\u2013 Gi\u00e1 tr\u1ecb 163.376 b\u1ea7u \u0111\u1ea5t l\u00e0 39.414.000 K\u00edp L\u00e0o, t\u01b0\u01a1ng \u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng 103.158.000 \u0111\u1ed3ng. T\u1ed5ng c\u1ed9ng C\u00f4ng ty T y\u00eau c\u1ea7u C\u00f4ng ty Q ph\u1ea3i thanh to\u00e1n l\u00e0 4.967.026.000 \u0111\u1ed3ng;<\/p>\n

\u2013 \u0110\u1ed1i v\u1edbi 449.455 c\u00e2y C\u00f4ng ty T m\u01b0\u1ee3n c\u1ee7a C\u00f4ng ty Q, \u0111\u00e3 tr\u1ea3 40.600 c\u00e2y, c\u00f2n l\u1ea1i 408.855 c\u00e2y, C\u00f4ng ty T \u0111\u1ed3ng \u00fd tr\u1ea3 b\u1eb1ng hi\u1ec7n v\u1eadt, kh\u00f4ng ch\u1ea5p nh\u1eadn tr\u1ea3 b\u1eb1ng ti\u1ec1n.<\/p>\n

T\u1ea1i B\u1ea3n \u00e1n kinh doanh, th\u01b0\u01a1ng m\u1ea1i s\u01a1 th\u1ea9m s\u1ed1 08\/2013\/KDTM-ST ng\u00e0y 04-9-2013, T\u00f2a \u00e1n nh\u00e2n d\u00e2n t\u1ec9nh Qu\u1ea3ng Tr\u1ecb quy\u1ebft \u0111\u1ecbnh:<\/p>\n

\u00c1p d\u1ee5ng kho\u1ea3n 1 \u0110i\u1ec1u 34, kho\u1ea3n 1 \u0110i\u1ec1u 35, kho\u1ea3n 1 \u0110i\u1ec1u 37, \u0110i\u1ec1u 54, 55, 56, 300, 301 c\u1ee7a Lu\u1eadt Th\u01b0\u01a1ng m\u1ea1i; kho\u1ea3n 1 \u0110i\u1ec1u 131 c\u1ee7a B\u1ed9 lu\u1eadt\u00a0T\u1ed1 t\u1ee5ng d\u00e2n s\u1ef1; kho\u1ea3n 4, kho\u1ea3n 5 \u0110i\u1ec1u 27 Ph\u00e1p l\u1ec7nh \u00c1n ph\u00ed, l\u1ec7 ph\u00ed T\u00f2a \u00e1n, x\u1eed:<\/p>\n

\u2013\u00a0Ch\u1ea5p nh\u1eadn y\u00eau c\u1ea7u kh\u1edfi ki\u1ec7n c\u1ee7a nguy\u00ean \u0111\u01a1n: Bu\u1ed9c b\u1ecb \u0111\u01a1n C\u00f4ng ty tr\u00e1ch nhi\u1ec7m h\u1eefu h\u1ea1n T ph\u1ea3i thanh to\u00e1n cho nguy\u00ean \u0111\u01a1n C\u00f4ng ty c\u1ed5 ph\u1ea7n Q s\u1ed1 ti\u1ec1n 1.720.888.500 \u0111\u1ed3ng.<\/p>\n

\u2013\u00a0Kh\u00f4ng ch\u1ea5p nh\u1eadn y\u00eau c\u1ea7u ph\u1ea3n t\u1ed1\u00a0c\u1ee7a\u00a0b\u1ecb \u0111\u01a1n \u0111\u1ed1i v\u1edbi s\u1ed1 ti\u1ec1n 3.602.837.000 \u0111\u1ed3ng.<\/p>\n

T\u00f2a \u00e1n c\u1ea5p s\u01a1 th\u1ea9m c\u00f2n quy\u1ebft \u0111\u1ecbnh v\u1ec1 \u00e1n ph\u00ed v\u00e0 quy\u1ec1n kh\u00e1ng c\u00e1o c\u1ee7a c\u00e1c \u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng s\u1ef1.<\/p>\n

Ng\u00e0y 04-9-2013, C\u00f4ng ty T c\u00f3 \u0111\u01a1n kh\u00e1ng c\u00e1o to\u00e0n b\u1ed9\u00a0b\u1ea3n \u00e1n s\u01a1 th\u1ea9m.<\/p>\n

Ng\u00e0y 01-10-2013, Vi\u1ec7n tr\u01b0\u1edfng Vi\u1ec7n ki\u1ec3m s\u00e1t nh\u00e2n d\u00e2n t\u1ec9nh Qu\u1ea3ng Tr\u1ecb c\u00f3 Quy\u1ebft \u0111\u1ecbnh kh\u00e1ng ngh\u1ecb s\u1ed1 2110\/Q\u0110KNPT-P12 kh\u00e1ng ngh\u1ecb B\u1ea3n \u00e1n kinh doanh, th\u01b0\u01a1ng m\u1ea1i s\u01a1 th\u1ea9m s\u1ed1 08\/2013\/KDTM-ST ng\u00e0y 04-9-2013 c\u1ee7a T\u00f2a \u00e1n nh\u00e2n d\u00e2n t\u1ec9nh Qu\u1ea3ng Tr\u1ecb.<\/p>\n

T\u1ea1i B\u1ea3n \u00e1n kinh doanh, th\u01b0\u01a1ng m\u1ea1i ph\u00fac th\u1ea9m s\u1ed1 19\/2014\/KDTM-PT ng\u00e0y 26-02-2014, T\u00f2a Ph\u00fac th\u1ea9m T\u00f2a \u00e1n nh\u00e2n d\u00e2n t\u1ed1i cao t\u1ea1i \u0110\u00e0 N\u1eb5ng quy\u1ebft \u0111\u1ecbnh:<\/p>\n

\u2013 \u0110\u00ecnh ch\u1ec9 x\u00e9t x\u1eed ph\u00fac th\u1ea9m \u0111\u1ed1i v\u1edbi kh\u00e1ng c\u00e1o c\u1ee7a b\u1ecb \u0111\u01a1n C\u00f4ng ty\u00a0tr\u00e1ch nhi\u1ec7m h\u1eefu h\u1ea1n T.<\/p>\n

\u2013 Kh\u00f4ng ch\u1ea5p nh\u1eadn Kh\u00e1ng ngh\u1ecb s\u1ed1 2110\/Q\u0110KNPT-P12 ng\u00e0y 01-10-2013 c\u1ee7a Vi\u1ec7n tr\u01b0\u1edfng Vi\u1ec7n ki\u1ec3m s\u00e1t nh\u00e2n d\u00e2n t\u1ec9nh Qu\u1ea3ng Tr\u1ecb. Gi\u1eef nguy\u00ean b\u1ea3n \u00e1n s\u01a1 th\u1ea9m.<\/p>\n

Sau khi x\u00e9t x\u1eed ph\u00fac th\u1ea9m, C\u00f4ng ty T c\u00f3 \u0111\u01a1n \u0111\u1ec1 ngh\u1ecb gi\u00e1m \u0111\u1ed1c th\u1ea9m \u0111\u1ed1i v\u1edbi\u00a0b\u1ea3n \u00e1n kinh doanh th\u01b0\u01a1ng m\u1ea1i ph\u00fac th\u1ea9m n\u00eau tr\u00ean.<\/p>\n

T\u1ea1i Kh\u00e1ng ngh\u1ecb gi\u00e1m \u0111\u1ed1c th\u1ea9m s\u1ed1 01\/2017\/KN-KDTM ng\u00e0y 24-02-2017, Ch\u00e1nh \u00e1n T\u00f2a \u00e1n nh\u00e2n d\u00e2n t\u1ed1i cao kh\u00e1ng ngh\u1ecb\u00a0B\u1ea3n \u00e1n kinh doanh, th\u01b0\u01a1ng m\u1ea1i ph\u00fac th\u1ea9m s\u1ed1 19\/2014\/KDTM-PT ng\u00e0y 26-02-2014 c\u1ee7a T\u00f2a Ph\u00fac th\u1ea9m T\u00f2a \u00e1n nh\u00e2n d\u00e2n t\u1ed1i cao t\u1ea1i \u0110\u00e0 N\u1eb5ng,\u00a0\u0111\u1ec1 ngh\u1ecb H\u1ed9i \u0111\u1ed3ng Th\u1ea9m ph\u00e1n T\u00f2a \u00e1n nh\u00e2n d\u00e2n t\u1ed1i cao h\u1ee7y b\u1ea3n \u00e1n kinh doanh, th\u01b0\u01a1ng m\u1ea1i ph\u00fac th\u1ea9m n\u00eau tr\u00ean v\u00e0 B\u1ea3n \u00e1n kinh doanh, th\u01b0\u01a1ng m\u1ea1i s\u01a1 th\u1ea9m s\u1ed1 08\/2013\/KDTM-ST ng\u00e0y 04-9-2013 c\u1ee7a T\u00f2a \u00e1n nh\u00e2n d\u00e2n t\u1ec9nh Qu\u1ea3ng Tr\u1ecb; giao h\u1ed3 s\u01a1 v\u1ee5 \u00e1n cho T\u00f2a \u00e1n nh\u00e2n d\u00e2n t\u1ec9nh Qu\u1ea3ng Tr\u1ecb x\u00e9t x\u1eed l\u1ea1i theo th\u1ee7 t\u1ee5c s\u01a1 th\u1ea9m \u0111\u00fang quy \u0111\u1ecbnh c\u1ee7a ph\u00e1p lu\u1eadt.<\/p>\n

T\u1ea1i phi\u00ean t\u00f2a gi\u00e1m \u0111\u1ed1c th\u1ea9m, \u0111\u1ea1i di\u1ec7n Vi\u1ec7n ki\u1ec3m s\u00e1t nh\u00e2n d\u00e2n t\u1ed1i cao \u0111\u1ec1 ngh\u1ecb H\u1ed9i \u0111\u1ed3ng Th\u1ea9m ph\u00e1n T\u00f2a \u00e1n nh\u00e2n d\u00e2n t\u1ed1i cao ch\u1ea5p nh\u1eadn kh\u00e1ng ngh\u1ecb c\u1ee7a Ch\u00e1nh \u00e1n T\u00f2a \u00e1n nh\u00e2n d\u00e2n t\u1ed1i cao.<\/p>\n

NH\u1eacN \u0110\u1ecaNH C\u1ee6A T\u00d2A \u00c1N:<\/strong><\/p>\n

[1] V\u1ec1 t\u1ed1 t\u1ee5ng: Theo Bi\u00ean b\u1ea3n phi\u00ean t\u00f2a ph\u00fac th\u1ea9m ng\u00e0y 26-11-2013 th\u00ec t\u1ea1i phi\u00ean t\u00f2a c\u00e1c \u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng s\u1ef1 c\u00f3 m\u1eb7t \u0111\u1ea7y \u0111\u1ee7 theo gi\u1ea5y tri\u1ec7u t\u1eadp c\u1ee7a T\u00f2a \u00e1n. Tuy nhi\u00ean, H\u1ed9i \u0111\u1ed3ng x\u00e9t x\u1eed \u0111\u00e3 quy\u1ebft \u0111\u1ecbnh ho\u00e3n phi\u00ean t\u00f2a \u0111\u1ec3 c\u00e1c \u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng s\u1ef1 cung c\u1ea5p th\u00eam ch\u1ee9ng c\u1ee9. T\u1ea1i phi\u00ean t\u00f2a ph\u00fac th\u1ea9m \u0111\u01b0\u1ee3c m\u1edf l\u1ea1i v\u00e0o ng\u00e0y 26-02-2014, b\u1ecb \u0111\u01a1n v\u00e0 lu\u1eadt s\u01b0\u00a0b\u1ea3o v\u1ec7 quy\u1ec1n v\u00e0 l\u1ee3i \u00edch h\u1ee3p ph\u00e1p c\u1ee7a b\u1ecb \u0111\u01a1n v\u1eafng m\u1eb7t. Tr\u01b0\u1eddng h\u1ee3p H\u1ed9i \u0111\u1ed3ng x\u00e9t x\u1eed \u0111\u00e3 quy\u1ebft \u0111\u1ecbnh ho\u00e3n phi\u00ean t\u00f2a v\u00e0 vi\u1ec7c ho\u00e3n phi\u00ean t\u00f2a l\u00e0 do T\u00f2a \u00e1n, t\u1ea1i phi\u00ean t\u00f2a \u0111\u01b0\u1ee3c m\u1edf l\u1ea1i \u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng s\u1ef1 ho\u1eb7c ng\u01b0\u1eddi \u0111\u1ea1i di\u1ec7n, ng\u01b0\u1eddi b\u1ea3o v\u1ec7 quy\u1ec1n v\u00e0 l\u1ee3i \u00edch h\u1ee3p ph\u00e1p c\u1ee7a \u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng s\u1ef1 v\u1eafng m\u1eb7t th\u00ec \u0111\u01b0\u1ee3c coi l\u00e0 v\u1eafng m\u1eb7t l\u1ea7n th\u1ee9 nh\u1ea5t. L\u1ebd ra, T\u00f2a \u00e1n c\u1ea5p ph\u00fac th\u1ea9m ph\u1ea3i x\u00e1c \u0111\u1ecbnh l\u00e0 b\u1ecb \u0111\u01a1n v\u00e0 lu\u1eadt s\u01b0 b\u1ea3o v\u1ec7 quy\u1ec1n v\u00e0 l\u1ee3i \u00edch h\u1ee3p ph\u00e1p c\u1ee7a b\u1ecb \u0111\u01a1n \u0111\u01b0\u1ee3c T\u00f2a \u00e1n tri\u1ec7u t\u1eadp h\u1ee3p l\u1ec7 l\u1ea7n th\u1ee9 nh\u1ea5t v\u1eafng m\u1eb7t t\u1ea1i phi\u00ean t\u00f2a theo quy \u0111\u1ecbnh t\u1ea1i kho\u1ea3n 1 \u0110i\u1ec1u 199, kho\u1ea3n 2 \u0110i\u1ec1u 266 B\u1ed9 lu\u1eadt T\u1ed1 t\u1ee5ng d\u00e2n s\u1ef1 \u0111\u1ec3 ho\u00e3n phi\u00ean t\u00f2a. T\u00f2a \u00e1n c\u1ea5p ph\u00fac th\u1ea9m nh\u1eadn \u0111\u1ecbnh t\u1ea1i phi\u00ean t\u00f2a ph\u00fac th\u1ea9m b\u1ecb \u0111\u01a1n v\u00e0 lu\u1eadt s\u01b0 b\u1ea3o v\u1ec7 quy\u1ec1n v\u00e0 l\u1ee3i \u00edch h\u1ee3p ph\u00e1p c\u1ee7a b\u1ecb \u0111\u01a1n \u0111\u00e3 \u0111\u01b0\u1ee3c T\u00f2a \u00e1n tri\u1ec7u t\u1eadp h\u1ee3p l\u1ec7 l\u1ea7n th\u1ee9 hai v\u1eafng m\u1eb7t t\u1ea1i phi\u00ean t\u00f2a, t\u1eeb \u0111\u00f3 \u0111\u00ecnh ch\u1ec9 x\u00e9t x\u1eed ph\u00fac th\u1ea9m \u0111\u1ed1i v\u1edbi y\u00eau c\u1ea7u kh\u00e1ng c\u00e1o c\u1ee7a b\u1ecb \u0111\u01a1n l\u00e0 kh\u00f4ng \u0111\u00fang quy \u0111\u1ecbnh t\u1ea1i \u0110i\u1ec1u 199, 202, 266 B\u1ed9 lu\u1eadt T\u1ed1 t\u1ee5ng d\u00e2n s\u1ef1, l\u00e0m m\u1ea5t quy\u1ec1n kh\u00e1ng c\u00e1o, \u1ea3nh h\u01b0\u1edfng \u0111\u1ebfn quy\u1ec1n v\u00e0 l\u1ee3i \u00edch h\u1ee3p ph\u00e1p c\u1ee7a b\u1ecb \u0111\u01a1n.<\/p>\n

[2] V\u1ec1 x\u00e1c \u0111\u1ecbnh l\u1ed7i c\u1ee7a c\u00e1c b\u00ean: Theo \u0110i\u1ec1u 3 H\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng mua b\u00e1n c\u00e2y gi\u1ed1ng cao su ng\u00e0y 03-01-2011, c\u00e1c b\u00ean th\u1ecfa thu\u1eadn ch\u1eadm nh\u1ea5t \u0111\u1ebfn ng\u00e0y 31-7-2011, B\u00ean B (C\u00f4ng ty T) ph\u1ea3i giao \u0111\u1ee7 s\u1ed1 l\u01b0\u1ee3ng 200.000 c\u00e2y \u0111\u1ea1t ti\u00eau chu\u1ea9n ch\u1ea5t l\u01b0\u1ee3ng cho B\u00ean A (C\u00f4ng ty Q). T\u1ea1i Bi\u00ean b\u1ea3n l\u00e0m vi\u1ec7c ng\u00e0y 15-7-2011 gi\u1eefa \u00f4ng H\u1ed3 Duy L l\u00e0 nh\u00e2n vi\u00ean Ph\u00f2ng K\u1ef9 thu\u1eadt n\u00f4ng nghi\u1ec7p C\u00f4ng ty Q v\u00e0\u00a0b\u00e0 V\u00f5 Th\u1ecb T \u0111\u1ea1i di\u1ec7n C\u00f4ng ty T v\u1ec1\u00a0vi\u1ec7c ti\u1ebfn h\u00e0nh ki\u1ec3m tra v\u00e0 \u0111\u00e1nh gi\u00e1 ch\u1ea5t l\u01b0\u1ee3ng c\u00e2y gi\u1ed1ng t\u1ea1i b\u00e3i t\u1eadp k\u1ebft \u0111\u1ebfn h\u1ebft ng\u00e0y 15-7-2011 ghi nh\u1eadn k\u1ebft qu\u1ea3:\u00a0\u201cStump b\u1ea7u t\u1ea7ng l\u00e1 chuy\u1ec3n ra b\u00e3i 15.550 b\u1ea7u; Stump b\u1ea7u t\u1ea7ng l\u00e1 chuy\u1ec3n ra b\u00e3i \u0111\u1ea1t t\u1eeb 2-3 t\u1ea7ng l\u00e1 tr\u1edf l\u00ean; t\u1ea7ng l\u00e1 \u1ed5n \u0111\u1ecbnh, ch\u1ea5t l\u01b0\u1ee3ng Stump b\u1ea7u t\u1ea7ng l\u00e1 t\u1ed1t\u201d.\u00a0T\u1eeb ng\u00e0y 15-7-2011 \u0111\u1ebfn ng\u00e0y 31-7-2011 (ng\u00e0y cu\u1ed1i c\u00f9ng th\u1ef1c hi\u1ec7n vi\u1ec7c giao nh\u1eadn c\u00e2y theo h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng) hai b\u00ean kh\u00f4ng giao nh\u1eadn c\u00e2y v\u00e0 c\u0169ng kh\u00f4ng c\u00f3 v\u0103n b\u1ea3n th\u1ecfa thu\u1eadn gia h\u1ea1n hay k\u00e9o d\u00e0i th\u1eddi h\u1ea1n giao nh\u1eadn c\u00e2y. C\u00f4ng ty Q cho r\u1eb1ng ng\u00e0y 15-7-2011 C\u00f4ng ty T m\u1edbi c\u00f3 15.550 c\u00e2y \u0111\u1ea1t ch\u1ea5t l\u01b0\u1ee3ng th\u00ec \u0111\u1ebfn ng\u00e0y 31-7-2011 kh\u00f4ng th\u1ec3 c\u00f3 \u0111\u1ee7 400.000 c\u00e2y \u0111\u1ec3 giao n\u00ean \u0111\u00e3 vi ph\u1ea1m h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng, c\u00f2n C\u00f4ng ty T cho r\u1eb1ng cho \u0111\u1ebfn h\u1ebft ng\u00e0y 31-7-2011 th\u00ec C\u00f4ng ty Q m\u1edbi ch\u1ec9 nh\u1eadn 3.268 c\u00e2y (d\u00f9 C\u00f4ng ty T \u0111\u00e3 c\u00f3 15.550 c\u00e2y \u0111\u1ec3 giao), n\u00ean C\u00f4ng ty Q \u0111\u00e3 vi ph\u1ea1m h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng.<\/p>\n

[3] T\u1ea1i Bi\u00ean b\u1ea3n phi\u00ean t\u00f2a ph\u00fac th\u1ea9m ng\u00e0y 26-11-2013, C\u00f4ng ty Q gi\u1ea3i th\u00edch l\u00fd do: \u0111\u1ebfn ng\u00e0y 31-7-2011 (ng\u00e0y cu\u1ed1i c\u00f9ng th\u1ef1c hi\u1ec7n vi\u1ec7c giao nh\u1eadn c\u00e2y theo h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng), C\u00f4ng ty Q kh\u00f4ng l\u1eadp bi\u00ean b\u1ea3n v\u1ec1 vi\u1ec7c giao nh\u1eadn c\u00e2y v\u00e0 \u0111\u1ebfn th\u00e1ng 9-2011 l\u1ea1i ti\u1ebfp t\u1ee5c th\u1ef1c hi\u1ec7n h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng nh\u1eadn c\u00e2y v\u00ec C\u00f4ng ty Q \u0111\u00e3 ki\u1ec3m tra nh\u01b0ng C\u00f4ng ty T ch\u1ec9 giao \u0111\u01b0\u1ee3c h\u01a1n 79.000 c\u00e2y. S\u1ed1 c\u00e2y c\u00f2n l\u1ea1i kh\u00f4ng \u0111\u1ee7 ti\u00eau chu\u1ea9n theo h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng \u0111\u1ec3 giao n\u00ean C\u00f4ng ty Q \u0111\u00e3 \u0111\u1ed3ng \u00fd cho k\u00e9o d\u00e0i th\u1eddi gian giao nh\u1eadn c\u00e2y \u0111\u1ec3 tr\u1eeb n\u1ee3 v\u00e0 cho ph\u00e9p C\u00f4ng ty T ti\u1ebfp t\u1ee5c ch\u0103m s\u00f3c c\u00e2y \u0111\u1ec3 \u0111\u1ee7 \u0111i\u1ec1u ki\u1ec7n giao c\u00e2y. \u0110\u1ed3ng th\u1eddi, \u00f4ng H (Tr\u01b0\u1edfng Ph\u00f2ng K\u1ef9 thu\u1eadt n\u00f4ng nghi\u1ec7p C\u00f4ng ty Q \u2013 l\u00e0 ng\u01b0\u1eddi l\u00e0m ch\u1ee9ng) \u0111\u00e3 gi\u1ea3i th\u00edch l\u00fd do \u0111\u1ebfn ng\u00e0y 31-7-2011 C\u00f4ng ty Q ch\u1ec9 nh\u1eadn 3.000 c\u00e2y l\u00e0 do C\u00f4ng ty Q ch\u1ec9 c\u00f3 03 xe \u00f4 t\u00f4 (02 xe Kazma v\u00e0 01 xe Isuzu), th\u1eddi \u0111i\u1ec3m n\u00e0y \u1edf L\u00e0o m\u01b0a, \u0111\u01b0\u1eddng x\u00e1 l\u1ea7y l\u1ed9i, b\u00e0 T c\u00f3 \u0111i\u1ec7n tho\u1ea1i l\u00ean C\u00f4ng ty Q b\u1ea3o l\u1ea5y c\u00e2y nh\u01b0ng do kh\u00f3 kh\u0103n n\u00ean C\u00f4ng ty Q kh\u00f4ng l\u1ea5y k\u1ecbp.<\/p>\n

[4]\u00a0V\u1edbi di\u1ec5n bi\u1ebfn s\u1ef1 vi\u1ec7c nh\u01b0 tr\u00ean, c\u00f3 th\u1ec3 x\u00e1c \u0111\u1ecbnh hai b\u00ean \u0111\u00e3 k\u00fd h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng quy \u0111\u1ecbnh th\u1eddi gian giao nh\u1eadn c\u00e2y t\u1eeb ng\u00e0y 30-6-2011 \u0111\u1ebfn ng\u00e0y 31-7-2011 v\u1edbi s\u1ed1 l\u01b0\u1ee3ng 200.000 c\u00e2y (t\u1ed5ng ph\u1ea3i giao theo 02 h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng l\u00e0 400.000 c\u00e2y). M\u1eb7c d\u00f9 \u0111\u1ebfn ng\u00e0y 15-7-2011, C\u00f4ng ty T \u0111\u00e3 c\u00f3 15.500 c\u00e2y \u0111\u1ec3 giao, nh\u01b0ng C\u00f4ng ty Q ch\u1ec9 nh\u1eadn 3.200 c\u00e2y do tr\u1eddi m\u01b0a, \u0111\u01b0\u1eddng x\u00e1 l\u1ea7y l\u1ed9i v\u00e0 ch\u1ec9 c\u00f3 03 xe v\u1eadn chuy\u1ec3n. Tuy kh\u00f4ng th\u1ec3 hi\u1ec7n b\u1eb1ng v\u0103n b\u1ea3n, nh\u01b0ng cho \u0111\u1ebfn ng\u00e0y 05-10-2011 th\u00ec C\u00f4ng ty Q \u0111\u00e3 ch\u1ea5p nh\u1eadn k\u00e9o d\u00e0i th\u1eddi gian giao nh\u1eadn c\u00e2y v\u00e0 ti\u1ebfp t\u1ee5c cam k\u1ebft s\u1ebd nh\u1eadn h\u1ebft c\u00e2y trong v\u00f2ng 12 ng\u00e0y. T\u00ednh \u0111\u1ebfn ng\u00e0y 21-9-2011, C\u00f4ng ty Q \u0111\u00e3 nh\u1eadn 79.924 c\u00e2y v\u00e0 \u0111\u1ebfn ng\u00e0y 24-10-2011 hai b\u00ean v\u1eabn ti\u1ebfn h\u00e0nh giao nh\u1eadn c\u00e2y (theo Bi\u00ean b\u1ea3n giao nh\u1eadn c\u00e2y gi\u1ed1ng ng\u00e0y 24-10-2011, trong \u0111\u00f3 x\u00e1c \u0111\u1ecbnh t\u1eeb ng\u00e0y 06-10-2011 \u0111\u1ebfn ng\u00e0y 24-10-2011 \u0111\u00e3 ti\u1ebfn h\u00e0nh giao nh\u1eadn 83.867 c\u00e2y gi\u1ed1ng PB260 ch\u1ee7ng lo\u1ea1i b\u1ea7u 2 t\u1ea7ng l\u00e1, ch\u1ea5t l\u01b0\u1ee3ng c\u00e2y gi\u1ed1ng t\u1ed1t). Do \u0111\u00f3, c\u00f3 c\u0103n c\u1ee9 x\u00e1c \u0111\u1ecbnh c\u1ea3 hai b\u00ean C\u00f4ng ty T v\u00e0 C\u00f4ng ty Q \u0111\u1ec1u c\u00f3 l\u1ed7i trong vi\u1ec7c giao c\u00e2y v\u00e0 nh\u1eadn c\u00e2y. T\u00f2a \u00e1n c\u1ea5p s\u01a1 th\u1ea9m v\u00e0 T\u00f2a \u00e1n c\u1ea5p ph\u00fac th\u1ea9m x\u00e1c \u0111\u1ecbnh l\u1ed7i ho\u00e0n to\u00e0n c\u1ee7a C\u00f4ng ty T v\u00e0 \u00e1p d\u1ee5ng m\u1ee9c ph\u1ea1t cao nh\u1ea5t theo \u0110i\u1ec1u 301 Lu\u1eadt Th\u01b0\u01a1ng m\u1ea1i (8%) \u0111\u1ed1i v\u1edbi C\u00f4ng ty T l\u00e0 kh\u00f4ng ph\u00f9 h\u1ee3p; c\u1ea7n ph\u1ea3i x\u00e1c \u0111\u1ecbnh l\u1ea1i m\u1ee9c \u0111\u1ed9 l\u1ed7i c\u1ee7a c\u00e1c b\u00ean \u0111\u1ec3 quy\u1ebft \u0111\u1ecbnh m\u1ee9c ph\u1ea1t cho \u0111\u00fang.<\/p>\n

[5] V\u1ec1 s\u1ed1 c\u00e2y m\u01b0\u1ee3n: H\u1ed3 s\u01a1 v\u1ee5 \u00e1n th\u1ec3 hi\u1ec7n 2 b\u00ean kh\u00f4ng c\u00f3 v\u0103n b\u1ea3n v\u1ec1 vi\u1ec7c m\u01b0\u1ee3n c\u00e2y, nh\u01b0ng c\u1ea3 2 b\u00ean \u0111\u1ec1u x\u00e1c nh\u1eadn C\u00f4ng ty Q cho C\u00f4ng ty T m\u01b0\u1ee3n 449.455 c\u00e2y, C\u00f4ng ty T \u0111\u00e3 tr\u1ea3 40.600 c\u00e2y, c\u00f2n n\u1ee3 408.855 c\u00e2y. C\u00f4ng ty T cho r\u1eb1ng \u0111\u00e3 c\u00f3 \u0111\u1ee7 c\u00e2y \u0111\u1ec3 tr\u1ea3 v\u00e0\u00a0\u0111\u1ed3ng \u00fd tr\u1ea3 b\u1eb1ng c\u00e2y, kh\u00f4ng ch\u1ea5p nh\u1eadn quy \u0111\u1ed5i tr\u1ea3 b\u1eb1ng ti\u1ec1n. C\u00f2n C\u00f4ng ty Q cho r\u1eb1ng do C\u00f4ng ty T kh\u00f4ng c\u00f3 kh\u1ea3 n\u0103ng tr\u1ea3 b\u1eb1ng c\u00e2y n\u00ean y\u00eau c\u1ea7u tr\u1ea3 b\u1eb1ng ti\u1ec1n. C\u0103n c\u1ee9 \u0110i\u1ec1u 471 v\u00e0 \u0110i\u1ec1u 474 B\u1ed9 lu\u1eadt D\u00e2n s\u1ef1 2005 v\u1ec1 h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng vay t\u00e0i s\u1ea3n; \u0110i\u1ec1u 514 B\u1ed9 lu\u1eadt D\u00e2n s\u1ef1 2005 v\u1ec1 h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng m\u01b0\u1ee3n t\u00e0i s\u1ea3n \u0111\u1ec1u quy \u0111\u1ecbnh v\u1ec1 ngh\u0129a v\u1ee5 tr\u1ea3 n\u1ee3 l\u00e0 b\u00ean vay (m\u01b0\u1ee3n) ph\u1ea3i ho\u00e0n tr\u1ea3 cho b\u00ean cho vay (cho m\u01b0\u1ee3n) t\u00e0i s\u1ea3n c\u00f9ng lo\u1ea1i, nh\u01b0ng T\u00f2a \u00e1n c\u1ea5p s\u01a1 th\u1ea9m v\u00e0 T\u00f2a \u00e1n c\u1ea5p ph\u00fac th\u1ea9m ch\u01b0a xem x\u00e9t vi\u1ec7c C\u00f4ng ty T c\u00f3 \u0111\u1ee7 kh\u1ea3 n\u0103ng tr\u1ea3 c\u00e2y c\u00f9ng lo\u1ea1i hay kh\u00f4ng l\u00e0 kh\u00f4ng ph\u00f9 h\u1ee3p quy \u0111\u1ecbnh c\u1ee7a ph\u00e1p lu\u1eadt. N\u1ebfu C\u00f4ng ty T kh\u00f4ng \u0111\u1ee7 kh\u1ea3 n\u0103ng \u0111\u1ec3 tr\u1ea3 b\u1eb1ng c\u00e2y c\u00f9ng lo\u1ea1i th\u00ec m\u1edbi bu\u1ed9c tr\u1ea3 b\u1eb1ng ti\u1ec1n.<\/p>\n

V\u00ec c\u00e1c l\u1ebd tr\u00ean,<\/p>\n

QUY\u1ebeT \u0110\u1ecaNH:<\/strong><\/p>\n

C\u0103n c\u1ee9 v\u00e0o kho\u1ea3n 2 \u0110i\u1ec1u 337, kho\u1ea3n 3 \u0110i\u1ec1u 343, \u0110i\u1ec1u 345 c\u1ee7a B\u1ed9 lu\u1eadt\u00a0T\u1ed1 t\u1ee5ng d\u00e2n s\u1ef1 n\u0103m 2015; Ngh\u1ecb quy\u1ebft s\u1ed1 103\/2015\/QH13 ng\u00e0y 25-11-2015 c\u1ee7a Qu\u1ed1c h\u1ed9i v\u1ec1 vi\u1ec7c thi h\u00e0nh B\u1ed9 lu\u1eadt T\u1ed1 t\u1ee5ng d\u00e2n s\u1ef1.<\/p>\n

1. Ch\u1ea5p nh\u1eadn Kh\u00e1ng ngh\u1ecb gi\u00e1m \u0111\u1ed1c th\u1ea9m s\u1ed1 01\/2017\/KN-KDTM ng\u00e0y 24-02-2017 c\u1ee7a Ch\u00e1nh \u00e1n T\u00f2a \u00e1n nh\u00e2n d\u00e2n t\u1ed1i cao \u0111\u1ed1i v\u1edbi B\u1ea3n \u00e1n kinh doanh, th\u01b0\u01a1ng m\u1ea1i ph\u00fac th\u1ea9m s\u1ed1 19\/2014\/KDTM-PT ng\u00e0y 26-02-2014 c\u1ee7a T\u00f2a Ph\u00fac th\u1ea9m T\u00f2a \u00e1n nh\u00e2n d\u00e2n t\u1ed1i cao t\u1ea1i \u0110\u00e0 N\u1eb5ng v\u1ec1 v\u1ee5 \u00e1n kinh doanh, th\u01b0\u01a1ng m\u1ea1i \u201cTranh ch\u1ea5p v\u1ec1 h\u1ee3p \u0111\u1ed3ng mua b\u00e1n h\u00e0ng h\u00f3a\u201d gi\u1eefa nguy\u00ean \u0111\u01a1n l\u00e0 C\u00f4ng ty c\u1ed5 ph\u1ea7n Q v\u1edbi b\u1ecb \u0111\u01a1n l\u00e0 C\u00f4ng ty tr\u00e1ch nhi\u1ec7m h\u1eefu h\u1ea1n T.<\/p>\n

2. H\u1ee7y B\u1ea3n \u00e1n kinh doanh, th\u01b0\u01a1ng m\u1ea1i ph\u00fac th\u1ea9m s\u1ed1 19\/2014\/KDTM-PT ng\u00e0y 26-02-2014 c\u1ee7a T\u00f2a Ph\u00fac th\u1ea9m T\u00f2a \u00e1n nh\u00e2n d\u00e2n t\u1ed1i cao t\u1ea1i \u0110\u00e0 N\u1eb5ng v\u00e0 B\u1ea3n \u00e1n kinh doanh, th\u01b0\u01a1ng m\u1ea1i s\u01a1 th\u1ea9m s\u1ed1 08\/2013\/KDTM-ST ng\u00e0y 04-9-2013 c\u1ee7a T\u00f2a \u00e1n nh\u00e2n d\u00e2n t\u1ec9nh Qu\u1ea3ng Tr\u1ecb.<\/p>\n

3. Giao h\u1ed3 s\u01a1 v\u1ee5 \u00e1n cho T\u00f2a \u00e1n nh\u00e2n d\u00e2n t\u1ec9nh Qu\u1ea3ng Tr\u1ecb \u0111\u1ec3 x\u00e9t x\u1eed l\u1ea1i theo th\u1ee7 t\u1ee5c s\u01a1 th\u1ea9m \u0111\u00fang quy \u0111\u1ecbnh c\u1ee7a ph\u00e1p lu\u1eadt.<\/p>\n

N\u1ed8I DUNG \u00c1N L\u1ec6<\/strong><\/p>\n

\u201c[1]\u00a0V\u1ec1 t\u1ed1 t\u1ee5ng: Theo Bi\u00ean b\u1ea3n phi\u00ean t\u00f2a ph\u00fac th\u1ea9m ng\u00e0y 26-11-2013 th\u00ec t\u1ea1i phi\u00ean t\u00f2a c\u00e1c \u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng s\u1ef1 c\u00f3 m\u1eb7t \u0111\u1ea7y \u0111\u1ee7 theo gi\u1ea5y tri\u1ec7u t\u1eadp c\u1ee7a T\u00f2a \u00e1n. Tuy nhi\u00ean, H\u1ed9i \u0111\u1ed3ng x\u00e9t x\u1eed \u0111\u00e3 quy\u1ebft \u0111\u1ecbnh ho\u00e3n phi\u00ean t\u00f2a \u0111\u1ec3 c\u00e1c \u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng s\u1ef1 cung c\u1ea5p th\u00eam ch\u1ee9ng c\u1ee9. T\u1ea1i phi\u00ean t\u00f2a ph\u00fac th\u1ea9m \u0111\u01b0\u1ee3c m\u1edf l\u1ea1i v\u00e0o ng\u00e0y 26-02-2014, b\u1ecb \u0111\u01a1n v\u00e0 lu\u1eadt s\u01b0 b\u1ea3o v\u1ec7 quy\u1ec1n v\u00e0 l\u1ee3i \u00edch h\u1ee3p ph\u00e1p c\u1ee7a b\u1ecb \u0111\u01a1n v\u1eafng m\u1eb7t. Tr\u01b0\u1eddng h\u1ee3p H\u1ed9i \u0111\u1ed3ng x\u00e9t x\u1eed \u0111\u00e3 quy\u1ebft \u0111\u1ecbnh ho\u00e3n phi\u00ean t\u00f2a v\u00e0 vi\u1ec7c ho\u00e3n phi\u00ean t\u00f2a l\u00e0 do T\u00f2a \u00e1n, t\u1ea1i phi\u00ean t\u00f2a \u0111\u01b0\u1ee3c m\u1edf l\u1ea1i \u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng s\u1ef1 ho\u1eb7c ng\u01b0\u1eddi \u0111\u1ea1i di\u1ec7n, ng\u01b0\u1eddi b\u1ea3o v\u1ec7 quy\u1ec1n v\u00e0 l\u1ee3i \u00edch h\u1ee3p ph\u00e1p c\u1ee7a \u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng s\u1ef1 v\u1eafng m\u1eb7t th\u00ec \u0111\u01b0\u1ee3c coi l\u00e0 v\u1eafng m\u1eb7t l\u1ea7n th\u1ee9 nh\u1ea5t. L\u1ebd ra, T\u00f2a \u00e1n c\u1ea5p ph\u00fac th\u1ea9m ph\u1ea3i x\u00e1c \u0111\u1ecbnh l\u00e0 b\u1ecb \u0111\u01a1n v\u00e0 lu\u1eadt s\u01b0 b\u1ea3o v\u1ec7 quy\u1ec1n v\u00e0 l\u1ee3i \u00edch h\u1ee3p ph\u00e1p c\u1ee7a b\u1ecb \u0111\u01a1n \u0111\u01b0\u1ee3c T\u00f2a \u00e1n tri\u1ec7u t\u1eadp h\u1ee3p l\u1ec7 l\u1ea7n th\u1ee9 nh\u1ea5t v\u1eafng m\u1eb7t t\u1ea1i phi\u00ean t\u00f2a theo quy \u0111\u1ecbnh t\u1ea1i kho\u1ea3n 1 \u0110i\u1ec1u 199, kho\u1ea3n 2 \u0110i\u1ec1u 266 B\u1ed9 lu\u1eadt T\u1ed1 t\u1ee5ng d\u00e2n s\u1ef1 \u0111\u1ec3 ho\u00e3n phi\u00ean t\u00f2a. T\u00f2a \u00e1n c\u1ea5p ph\u00fac th\u1ea9m nh\u1eadn \u0111\u1ecbnh t\u1ea1i phi\u00ean t\u00f2a ph\u00fac th\u1ea9m b\u1ecb \u0111\u01a1n v\u00e0 lu\u1eadt s\u01b0 b\u1ea3o v\u1ec7 quy\u1ec1n v\u00e0 l\u1ee3i \u00edch h\u1ee3p ph\u00e1p c\u1ee7a b\u1ecb \u0111\u01a1n \u0111\u00e3 \u0111\u01b0\u1ee3c T\u00f2a \u00e1n tri\u1ec7u t\u1eadp h\u1ee3p l\u1ec7 l\u1ea7n th\u1ee9 hai v\u1eafng m\u1eb7t t\u1ea1i phi\u00ean t\u00f2a, t\u1eeb \u0111\u00f3 \u0111\u00ecnh ch\u1ec9 x\u00e9t x\u1eed ph\u00fac th\u1ea9m \u0111\u1ed1i v\u1edbi y\u00eau c\u1ea7u kh\u00e1ng c\u00e1o c\u1ee7a b\u1ecb \u0111\u01a1n l\u00e0 kh\u00f4ng \u0111\u00fang quy \u0111\u1ecbnh t\u1ea1i \u0110i\u1ec1u 199, 202, 266 B\u1ed9 lu\u1eadt T\u1ed1 t\u1ee5ng d\u00e2n s\u1ef1, l\u00e0m m\u1ea5t quy\u1ec1n kh\u00e1ng c\u00e1o, \u1ea3nh h\u01b0\u1edfng \u0111\u1ebfn quy\u1ec1n v\u00e0 l\u1ee3i \u00edch h\u1ee3p ph\u00e1p c\u1ee7a b\u1ecb \u0111\u01a1n.\u201d<\/em><\/p>\n

\u00bb Lu\u1eadt s\u01b0 b\u1ea3o v\u1ec7 quy\u1ec1n l\u1ee3i v\u1ee5 \u00e1n d\u00e2n s\u1ef1<\/a><\/p>\n

\u00bb Lu\u1eadt s\u01b0 b\u1ea3o v\u1ec7 d\u00e2n s\u1ef1<\/a><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<\/div>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"

\u00c1n l\u1ec7 s\u1ed1 12\/2017\/AL v\u1ec1 x\u00e1c \u0111\u1ecbnh tr\u01b0\u1eddng h\u1ee3p \u0111\u01b0\u01a1ng s\u1ef1 \u0111\u01b0\u1ee3c tri\u1ec7u t\u1eadp h\u1ee3p l\u1ec7 l\u1ea7n th\u1ee9 nh\u1ea5t sau khi T\u00f2a \u00e1n \u0111\u00e3 ho\u00e3n phi\u00ean t\u00f2a, \u0111\u01b0\u1ee3c H\u1ed9i \u0111\u1ed3ng Th\u1ea9m ph\u00e1n T\u00f2a \u00e1n nh\u00e2n d\u00e2n t\u1ed1i cao th\u00f4ng qua ng\u00e0y 14 th\u00e1ng 12 n\u0103m 2017 v\u00e0 \u0111\u01b0\u1ee3c c\u00f4ng b\u1ed1 theo Quy\u1ebft \u0111\u1ecbnh s\u1ed1 299\/Q\u0110-CA […]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"closed","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[194],"tags":[],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/luatsubaoho.com\/phapluat\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/17738"}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/luatsubaoho.com\/phapluat\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/luatsubaoho.com\/phapluat\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/luatsubaoho.com\/phapluat\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/1"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/luatsubaoho.com\/phapluat\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=17738"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/luatsubaoho.com\/phapluat\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/17738\/revisions"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/luatsubaoho.com\/phapluat\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=17738"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/luatsubaoho.com\/phapluat\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=17738"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/luatsubaoho.com\/phapluat\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=17738"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}